Swing Setups: strategies, tested
33 published trading strategies went through a 20-year test on NSE data, with a decade kept aside they were never chosen on, costs doubled, every nearby setting and tax. Two are kept, each with a trailing stop. Each is written as exact rules, with its full record. Swing Setups teaches how they work; it never says what to trade.
- 2Strategies kept
- 33Strategies tested
- 20Years tested
The strategies 2
The two kept, out of 33 tried. The curves are the live backtest since 2016, run after every close on NSE's 500 most-traded stocks after costs, against the Nifty 500 index. Open one for its exact rules, its 20-year record and how it held up under stress.
Momentum + Low Volatility
NSE's factor indices (momentum and low volatility)StrategyNifty 500A year since 2016+19.1%Worst fall since 2016−36.7%A year, 2006 to 2026+19.0%A year after tax, 20 years+15.5%Beat the Nifty 500 (+12.2%/yr)Trend leadersTop returnOne test shortTrend Template
Mark MinerviniStrategyNifty 500A year since 2016+19.4%Worst fall since 2016−55.7%A year, 2006 to 2026+24.1%A year after tax, 20 years+19.7%Beat the Nifty 500 (+12.2%/yr)How the strategies were chosen and tested
The tests every strategy here had to pass, how each test is run, and how to read the results.
01How they were chosen
- Twenty years, a decade kept aside
- 33 published strategies were tested on NSE's end-of-day files from 2006: the 24 that Swing Setups used to show, six from academic research and NSE's factor indices, and three more, each with its rules written down before any result was seen. The years 2006 to 2015 were not used to pick anything, so they show how each did on data it was never fitted to. Two are kept: Momentum + Low Volatility, which cleared every test, and Trend Template, which cleared every test but the last (its page says so). They are the two whose lead over the index held in both decades; a later round of three new designs did not pass on the unseen years.
- The bar they had to clear
- Beat the index in 2006 to 2015, and again in 2016 to 2026.
- Still beat it with costs doubled.
- Give similar results with nearby settings: more or fewer stocks, other rebalance days, other lookbacks.
- Beat a portfolio of 20 stocks picked at random.
- Stay statistically significant after allowing for every strategy tried, since some will look good by luck alone.
- What did not make it
- Trailed the index
In both decades, once costs were paid: every short-term pullback strategy, every quick breakout and the futures long build-up.
- RSI-2
- Cumulative RSI
- Stochastic
- NR7
- Inside bar
- Bollinger squeeze
- Turtle
- Ichimoku
- Keltner
- Breakaway gap
- Long build-up
- Not convincing
Beat the index, but not by enough to be sure it was more than luck, or only with one setup.
- Darvas Box
- EMA 20/50
- Pocket Pivot
- 52-Week High
- RS-Line High
- Golden Cross
- Came closest
Delivery Accumulation: far ahead from 2006 to 2015, it only matched the index from 2016, and fell behind with costs doubled.
In Indian shares, trends that last months have paid; short swings have not.
- Trailed the index
02How every test is run
- Universe
- The 500 most-traded NSE stocks at each date, by six-month average traded value, re-ranked every month, including companies that later stopped trading (131 of the 1,361 since 2016). Testing only today's survivors would flatter every result.
- Trading
- Rules are read at a day's close and the portfolio changes at the next day's open. Momentum + Low Volatility holds up to 20 stocks, chosen again on the first trading day of each month; Trend Template holds up to 10 trades at a time, each a tenth of the money.
- Trailing stops
- Every strategy has a stop below each holding that only ever rises: after each close it moves up if the stock has gained enough, and never down. A close below it closes the trade at the next open. Both sit 25% below the highest close, so they act only on a deep fall: in the monthly portfolio the money then goes at once to the next best-ranked stock. Each strategy's page shows its record with and without the stop.
- Costs
- 0.2% on each side of every trade (STT, stamp duty, exchange charges and slippage). Every strategy is also run with costs doubled.
- Tax
- Each strategy's 20-year record is also shown after capital-gains tax at today's rates (20% on gains held under a year, 12.5% after), against an index fund that pays tax only once.
- Live backtest
- 1 Jan 2016 to 18 Nov 2026, rerun on NSE's files after every close. Splits, bonus issues, demergers and symbol changes are joined up, so none shows up as a gain or a loss.
- What is left out
- Dividends (as in the Nifty 500 price index it is measured against) and the chance that a large order moves a thinly traded price.
03Reading the results
- No stocks to act on
- Swing Setups does not list the stocks that meet a strategy's rules or that it would hold today. A stock is named only in past trades that ended at least three months before the latest data, to show how the rules worked.
- What to expect
- Both hold stocks that are already rising, so they tend to do well and badly at the same times: they have led in trending markets and lagged in choppy ones and in sharp rebounds (2009, 2016, 2018, 2022, 2025). Each has had stretches of two to five years behind the index.
Swing Setups is a screen and a history lesson, not advice. RupeeVerse is not registered with SEBI as an investment adviser or research analyst. Stocks named in past backtest trades are examples of how the rules worked, not recommendations, and past results do not predict future ones. Do your own research.